The acquittal of Lev Panfilov and other accused persons must not only restore legal standing, but livelihood as well.

Key points at a glance:
- Winning an acquittal in Singapore clears a defendant’s name, yet leaves their life broken.
- Cleared defendants still face permanent online stigma and massive legal bills they must pay themselves.
- Current law only compensates victims when prosecutors act maliciously, ignoring honest mistakes by the state.
- Singapore should protect pre-trial anonymity, subsidise middle-income defence costs, and compensate wrongful imprisonment.
In an earlier article, we argued that Singapore’s oft-cited 4% figure counts only the false sexual reports police identified and acted on. It cannot tell us how common fabricated accusations really are.
This article asks a different question. Even if wrongful accusations were rare, what does Singapore owe a person whose life is damaged by one?
A Conviction Overturned, a Life not Restored

In March 2025, Lev Panfilov was convicted of four sexual offences and sentenced in May to 11½ years’ imprisonment and 12 strokes of the cane. In September 2026, the Court of Appeal unanimously acquitted him.
The High Court had found the complainant “unusually convincing”. Testing her account against the other evidence, the appellate judges disagreed:
- The scream. At trial she said she had not screamed. The doctor who examined her six days later had recorded, at the time, that she said she did scream and was silenced. A flatmate at home that night heard no commotion.
- The underwear. Bloodstained underwear offered as evidence was retrieved from a laundry basket days later, after the complainant’s period. Panfilov’s description of the garment differed, and medical evidence could not establish that the blood came from the alleged assault.
- The memo. A GP testified that the complainant sought a medical memo to confront Panfilov’s family, then asked to cancel the consultation record. She could not recall making either request.
The court found reasonable doubt. It did not find that she lied, and we do not suggest otherwise.
The ordeal still cost Panfilov dearly. He twice sought permission to visit his dying father in Russia, but both requests were refused. He was allowed to travel only for the funeral. When permission to visit his ailing grandfather was also refused, he tried to leave using an undeclared second passport and was remanded. He later described that decision as foolish.
In all, he spent almost three years in custody. His family spent around S$500,000, and a scholarship to study acting in New York was lost.
The Court of Appeal corrected his conviction. But much of what Panfilov lost during the years of criminal proceedings consisted of things that money cannot return.
Protecting Reputations Before and After Acquittal

Sexual-offence complainants are generally protected by gag orders. Yet defendants can be named and photographed from the day they are charged, and that association can follow them in search results for years, whatever the verdict. In an October 2026 interview with CNA, Panfilov said he was “basically treated as if I was guilty” before his case had been decided.
Singapore should consider two reforms.
First, people accused of sexual offences should remain anonymous until conviction. Judges could permit identification where there is a compelling public interest, such as encouraging other witnesses to come forward.
Second, an acquitted person should be able to return to ordinary life without being treated as a rapist or abuser who merely escaped conviction. The prosecution’s failure to establish guilt should not leave him carrying a lifelong burden of disproving the accusation. Equally, his acquittal does not establish that the complainant deliberately lied. Respecting the presumption of innocence requires holding both principles together.
This principle is not new. In XP v Public Prosecutor [2008], Justice V. K. Rajah warned against maintaining an “insidious and open-ended suspicion of guilt” after someone has been acquitted. Such insinuations, he explained, undermine the presumption of innocence and leave an acquitted person struggling to escape suspicion even after vindication in court.
Singapore’s existing media guidance already recognises that an accused person is innocent until proven guilty. Reporting standards should give that principle fuller effect. Where a defendant has been named, an acquittal should receive prominence comparable to the original charge, and online reports and reference material should be updated.
The public record often falls short. In 2012, Ong Mingwee’s rape conviction was overturned, with the High Court also accepting his good-faith belief that the complainant had consented. Yet AWARE’s online consent guide still cites the lower court’s reasoning against him without mentioning his acquittal.
After Panfilov’s acquittal, AWARE stated in an Instagram post: “The courts have made it clear: Acquittal does not mean innocent.” If a decision by Singapore’s highest court cannot settle public suspicion, it is hard to see what can.
The Price of Defending Yourself

In 2017, Dr Yeo Sow Nam was accused of molesting a woman four times at his clinic. During the trial, the complainant admitted under cross-examination to lying about parts of her evidence, including her claim to remember Dr Yeo resting his hand on her hip. CCTV footage supported his defence, and prosecutors withdrew all charges in 2021. By then, Dr Yeo and his wife had spent more than S$600,000.
Most defences cost far less, but the gap between those who can afford a full defence and those who cannot is real.
The Public Defender’s Office, established in 2022, assists defendants of limited means. Although eligibility was expanded in October 2026, middle-income families may still earn too much to qualify while being unable to afford a prolonged trial costing tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Singapore should therefore consider subsidies for middle-income defendants who do not qualify for existing legal aid, with additional help when a case becomes exceptionally costly. That help must come while the case is running. A family that exhausts its savings halfway through a trial cannot wait for an acquittal to learn whether it will be reimbursed.
After Acquittal: Who Covers the Loss?

Even when every charge fails, an acquitted person generally bears his own legal costs. There is a clear inequity of burden here, where the state prosecutes in the public interest at public expense, while the accused is forced to defend himself at his own expense.
Some financial relief is already available under Singapore law, but the circumstances in which it can be obtained are limited. Singapore’s Criminal Procedure Code allows acquitted defendants to recover their legal costs where the prosecution was frivolous or vexatious. The same test applies to a separate compensation provision, capped at S$10,000. Appellate courts also have powers to award costs.
But these provisions do not establish a general right to recover defence expenses or other losses simply because a person has been acquitted.
Parti Liyani’s case shows how narrow that route is. The former domestic worker was sentenced to 26 months’ jail for theft and acquitted on appeal in 2020. For nearly four years, she could not work and relied on the migrant workers’ group HOME. She sought the S$10,000 maximum. The High Court refused, holding that the prosecution was not frivolous or vexatious because a reasonable prosecutor could have considered the evidence sufficient for trial.
Even if that test suits its purpose, which is deterring improper prosecutions, it was never designed to compensate people harmed by proper prosecutions that fail.
Again, this is not just a question of whether prosecutors behaved properly. Criminal prosecutions are brought on behalf of society, but the financial burden of resisting them often falls on individuals.
Even when an acquittal shows that guilt was not established, the accused may be left with debts accumulated while defending himself. Why should the public interest justify spending taxpayers’ money to prosecute, but never justify helping an acquitted person recover reasonable defence costs? Should the justice system protect the interests of those reporting crimes while leaving acquitted defendants to bear the financial consequences alone?
Other jurisdictions offer broader remedies. Germany compensates qualifying detention after acquittal, including financial losses and €75 per day of lost liberty. Japan recognises a constitutional right to seek compensation following detention and acquittal. New Zealand’s guidelines provide approximately NZ$150,000 per year of wrongful imprisonment, although applicants normally must establish their innocence on the balance of probabilities.
Singapore could therefore consider two reforms:
- Reimburse reasonable defence costs. Courts could be given discretion to reimburse these after an acquittal, even where prosecutors acted properly, with the amount independently assessed.
- Compensate serious miscarriages of justice. A separate scheme could cover wrongful imprisonment, lost income and other substantial losses, adjusted where the claimant’s own conduct contributed to the harm.
The state need not have acted wrongly for someone to have suffered a serious injustice through its processes.
When Institutions Err

In 2020, the Court of Appeal overturned Dr Wee Teong Boo’s ten-year sentence. The trial judge had acquitted him of rape but convicted him of sexual assault by digital penetration. The prosecution had never alleged this, and the complainant had expressly denied it. The appellate court held this was an error of law that substantially prejudiced him. It also criticised the prosecution for disclosing material evidence, including a medical report helpful to the defence, only after the trial had begun.
Singapore has mechanisms to discipline judges and prosecutors. But they address misconduct. They do not necessarily explain to the public what went wrong when a serious conviction collapses, or what has changed since.
We should therefore consider independent reviews of serious miscarriages of justice. Such reviews could examine evidence handling, disclosure, legal reasoning and court procedures to establish what went wrong, whether existing safeguards failed and what should change. Their findings should be published where appropriate, with disciplinary action following where the evidence establishes negligence or misconduct.
Judicial independence deserves protection, but examining grave errors and holding individuals accountable where negligence or misconduct is established need not compromise it.
Justice Beyond the Verdict
Singapore’s appellate courts have shown they will overturn convictions the evidence cannot sustain. That safeguard is indispensable.
But the consequences of an accusation reach beyond the courtroom. A name can be damaged before trial, a family can exhaust its savings, and an error can cost years of freedom. After an acquittal, there may be no clear way to recover what was lost.
The courts can correct verdicts and the media should correct the record. Likewise, our state can widen access to defence, learn from its errors and compensate those its system has failed.
If Singapore is serious about justice, it must also be serious about repairing the harm when the pursuit of justice goes wrong.
[…] We take a deeper look at the costs born by victims of false accusations and as the reforms needed to address them in When Justice Gets It Wrong, Who Pays? […]