With entire livelihoods at stake in sexual assault accusations, Singapore needs clearer, more comprehensive case outcomes.

Key points at a glance:
- Official figures show that only 4% of sexual assault reports lead to false-reporting charges.
- However, that number only counts cases where police proved an accuser knowingly lied.
- Many other cases end without charges, or get recorded under crimes like cheating and assault.
- An acquittal does not prove a lie, yet false claims still ruin innocent lives.
- Singapore should publish clearer case outcomes instead of treating 4% as the whole picture.
In September 2026, former Wah!Banana actor Lev Panfilov walked out of the Court of Appeal a free man. A year earlier, a High Court judge had found his accuser’s evidence “unusually convincing” and sentenced him to 11½ years’ imprisonment and 12 strokes of the cane for four sexual offences. The Court of Appeal unanimously overturned every conviction. It found material inconsistencies in his accuser’s account that she could not credibly explain.
A lesser-known case from 2025 ended differently. A man whom Claris Ling Min Rui had met on Sugarbook refused to pay her S$1,200 after consensual sex. She threatened to accuse him of rape and then filed a false police report. When hotel CCTV footage contradicted her account, she admitted lying. Her penalty was Probation.
The two cases are somewhat different. Ling admitted to lying, but the court in Panfilov’s case found reasonable doubt that he was guilty, not that his accuser lied. Together, though, they raise two questions. How often are sexual accusations deliberately invented? And how reliable are the figures we use to answer that?
MHA’s 2019 Statistic: 4%
In a 2019 parliamentary reply, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) reported an average of about 250 reports of rape and sexual assault by penetration per year between 2014 and 2018. Each year, police charged or warned about 10 complainants for false reporting. That is roughly 4%, and the figure is now widely cited as evidence that false accusations are rare.
But look a little closer and one sees that the other 240 cases tell a less tidy story:
- About 130 ended with no further action because investigations found no offence disclosed.
- About 60 ended with warnings to the alleged offenders.
- About 50 were prosecuted.
Each category leaves questions unanswered.
The 130 no-further-action cases are the largest blind spot. Some may have been genuine assaults that could not be proved. Others may have involved misunderstandings or conduct that was not criminal. Some may have been fabrications that investigators suspected but could not prove. The figures do not say how many fall into each group.
The 60 warnings are ambiguous. These cases began as reports of rape or sexual assault by penetration. Did investigations substantiate the allegation, uncover lesser wrongdoing, or simply find too little evidence to prosecute?
The 50 prosecutions leave a gap too. In 2019, then-Nominated MP Anthea Ong asked what proportion of sexual-offence prosecutions ended in conviction. MHA did not provide that figure. We know how many cases reached court, but not how many ended in acquittal, as Panfilov’s did.
In short, what the 4% figure tells us is how often police identified and acted against false reporting, either through investigation or a confession. But it cannot tell us how many of the remaining allegations were false.
Some False Accusations are Recorded as Other Crimes

Some false sexual accusations never appear in false-reporting statistics, because they are prosecuted under other offences.
In 2018, Chua Sok Min was jailed for four weeks for assaulting a taxi driver after she refused to pay her fare. According to the agreed facts, she falsely accused him of molestation, made false police calls and told officers he had tried to rape her. The driver’s video recording helped establish what really happened. Instead of this being recognised as a case of false reporting, she was convicted of causing hurt.
In 2025, Chang Wai Chain was jailed for 11 months for cheating a man she met on Sugarbook. She claimed to be 17, impersonated her own brother, and threatened to report the man for underage sexual activity unless he paid. He transferred S$8,100, although no sexual activity had occurred. Prosecutors noted that her conduct could have amounted to extortion. Chang never filed a false complaint. She didn’t need to, because the threat alone was enough to frighten the man into paying her S$8,100.
Anyone counting only false-reporting cases would miss both. We do not know how many similar cases sit under assault, cheating or extortion. As these cases are filed under different offences, researchers searching for false sexual accusations may never find them unless they examine the underlying facts. Over time, this makes it harder to identify how frequently such accusations have been used.
The Proof Problem

False accusations are also hard to count because proving that someone knowingly lied is difficult.
Consider how Claris Ling confessed only after CCTV contradicted her. And in another case, Liau Wan Ting falsely accused her former boyfriend of rape in January 2026. She initially maintained her story during police questioning before eventually admitting that their sexual encounter had been consensual. She was sentenced to five weeks’ imprisonment.
A confession is not always necessary to identify a case of false allegations, however. In 2026, a Hong Kong court convicted Isabel Rose of blackmail and perverting the course of justice after a full trial. It examined her messages and concluded she had fabricated a rape allegation against a banker. But consider how that outcome depended on documentary evidence being made available. That will not exist in every case, which is another reason why false accusations are difficult to establish.
In some cases, even the complainant’s own admissions to lying may not be enough to result in a case being classified as one involving false accusations. In Dr Yeo Sow Nam’s molestation trial, the complainant admitted under cross-examination to lying about parts of her evidence, and prosecutors even withdrew all four charges in 2021. Yet the Attorney-General’s Chambers maintained that deliberate fabrication of the alleged molestation had not been established.
Even when the police have serious doubts, without a confession or strong independent evidence, they may not be able to prove deliberate fabrication. The result is that such cases are not counted as false reports. Instead, they slip by, unidentified, among the other outcomes.
Why Getting the Numbers Right Matters

The consequences of a sexual accusation can be devastating. Time, money and reputation are all at stake. Panfilov spent almost three years in custody, and his family spent around S$500,000 on his defense. Dr Yeo Sow Nam and his wife spent more than S$600,000, and he lost his post as a visiting consultant at a public hospital. Even after acquittal, the damage to someone’s reputation can persist for years. The accusation may continue to follow him long after the courts have cleared him.
We take a deeper look at the costs born by victims of false accusations and the reforms needed to address them in When Justice Gets It Wrong, Who Pays?
So, when the narrow 4% figure is used to suggest that false accusations are vanishingly rare, these consequences become easier to dismiss as a marginal issue unworthy of scrutiny. This is why our statistics should report the true extent of the problem, beyond what official conviction rates indicate.
Yet not every failed accusation is a lie. None of this means that every complainant whose case fails should be suspected of false reporting. A woman may indeed have been assaulted and still be unable to prove it. Likewise, an acquittal means the prosecution did not prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. It does not necessarily mean the complainant lied. If complainants feared prosecution whenever a defendant was acquitted, genuine victims would stop reporting.
But this creates an uncomfortable tension. When a man is acquitted, he should be able to return to his life with the full presumption of innocence restored. It is wrong to treat him as an un-convicted rapist or abuser simply because the court could not establish exactly what happened. He should not have to spend the rest of his life disproving an accusation that the prosecution failed to prove. At the same time, an acquittal does not establish that the complainant deliberately fabricated her allegation. She should not automatically be branded a liar simply because her accusation failed.
Both principles must hold. An acquitted man must not be treated as guilty, and an unsuccessful complainant must not automatically be treated as dishonest. Sometimes the evidence simply cannot establish what happened. That uncertainty must not become an excuse to presume guilt in either direction.
The line must be clear. Knowingly fabricating a sexual accusation is a serious offence and should be punished accordingly. Yet, failing to prove an assault is not fabrication. Because our justice system is credible, it is able to tell the two apart. But then, so should credible statistics.
So what should Singapore do?

Three modest steps would help.
- Record fabrication wherever it is found. When investigations establish that someone knowingly made a false sexual accusation, that finding should be logged even if the person is charged with assault, cheating or another offence. Threats to make such accusations, as in Chang’s case, should also be recorded, but in a separate category. Such cases can reveal how the threat of a sexual allegation is deliberately used to intimidate or exploit others, even when no false police report is actually made.
- Publish fuller outcomes. MHA should periodically release figures for sexual-offence reports showing no further action, warnings, prosecutions, convictions and acquittals, with broad reasons why cases were closed. Researchers could then distinguish unsubstantiated allegations, non-criminal conduct and proven falsehoods, instead of treating every unresolved case as either genuine or fabricated.
- Stop treating 4% as a prevalence estimate. It only measures identified false-reporting cases, but not the full prevalence of fabricated sexual accusations. It is a floor. Not a total. Researchers, journalists and advocacy groups should describe it that way.
None of this requires assuming that false accusations are common. It requires admitting what we don’t know. We should not use a narrow statistic to dismiss a problem whose full extent we have never properly measured.
Better data is only a beginning. In a companion article, we ask what Singapore owes people who lose their freedom, savings and reputations to accusations or convictions that are later overturned.

[…] an earlier article, we argued that Singapore’s oft-cited 4% figure counts only the false sexual reports police […]